December book challenge

 This year I have read 44 books. My favorite book is Firefly Summer by Maeve Binchy.



Dec*1 ~likeness: historical mystery series

Her Royal Spyness (Royal Spyness #1)



Author: Rhys Bowen

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 324

First published: 2007

Setting: Scotland and London in 1932

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: There are two disadvantages to being a minor royal.

One sentence comment: It’s the latest historical mystery seies I started to read, and the first book put me into laughter mode often.

     At first I had suspected if I wanted to buy a book about the royal family. However, when I started to read, I found this is a book exactly for me that didn’t care for royal family affairs. Through this book, I remind myself that we shouldn’t see things as they appear on the surface.

The narrator is a down-and-out 21-year-old distant relative of the queen. She had to strive for her survival like most young people who started to make their living. The downside was that a royal member was not supposed to work. Surprisingly, there were so many of them, young and powerless to a new world then. Bowen must be a genius that she captures the tone and voice of young girls on top of the society, as if I were watching the TV series Downtown Abbey. The only thing why the book didn’t get my five stars is that I am too much of a serious temperament for a book full of playful and sharp-tongued jokes.

 

Dec *2~likeness: historical mystery series

Murder on Lenox Hill (Gaslight Mystery #7)



Author: Victoria Thompson

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 291

First published: 2005

Setting: New York in late 19th century

Rating: stars

First sentence: The weather was so miserable, even Mrs. Ellsworth was indoors, Sarah Brandt noted as she hurried down the windy street to her house.

One sentence comment: I have always wanted to know more about what would happen to the characters in the series.

     This is the first historical mystery series I have been following since 2021. I only read two or three books a year, thus I am able to check whether I would grow out of my favor of the series.

     The dual point of views from both protagonists, Sarah and Frank, a midwife and police officer, give me snapshots of the last few years of the 19th century New York, from its upper class, immigrants, to gutters. In this book, the focus is on a church preacher who devotes to fatherless boys.

     The  character development is overwhelming. Sarah has taken in an orphan girl, who was once traumatized with unknown reasons to us, so she could not speak. Frank's son has gone into a school to learn a sign language. Another fun is that Theodore Roosevelt, who was on top of the police force before becoming the 26th president in 1898, is lurking in the background.

 

Dec *3~likeness: historical mystery series

Where Serpents Sleep (Sebastian St. Cyr Mystery #4)



Author: C. S. Harris

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 346

First published: 2008

Setting: London in 1812

Rating: stars

First sentence: The girl stared out the window, one hand sliding up and down her shawl – covered arm in a ceaseless, uneasy motion.

One sentence comment: I have admired with excitement the characterization and dialogues in the series.

     This is my favorite historical mystery series to follow. Somehow Harris gives me the feels of the 19th century French authors, Dumas and Hugo, whom I read as a child. The first fun part of this book is that – while the weak Regent was facing Luddites, those who hid their faces and smashed machines in the country, the prime minister Perceval equates the former American colonies with the new satanic threat from the bible prophesy. America was trying to annex Canada at the time. I love the peripheral part of the story that the Prince was tough with America, defending the interest of Canada and British shipping interests.

On the personal level, I love domestic affairs of lord Jarvis, the antagonist of the series. Her daughter Hero, against her father’s conservative attitude, was taking the lead to investigate the crime that had involved her as a witness. Hero started to take a major role telling her feelings. It reminded of my feelings when I grew up, such as “there were times when the contrast between the way lady Jarvis was now and the way Hero remembered her was enough to bring the sting of tears to her eyes.” It is forever a pang that you see someone you love deteriorating.

Harris is my favorite author because her books follow well-reasearched events and she is wise enough to bring about lively characters to show the world within and outside them. She said “At the same time that Sebastian is evolving and changing, we watch Britain and the world around him change, too.”

https://crimereads.com/how-do-you-keep-a-long-running-series-fresh-the-secret-is-character/

 

Dec *4~likeness: historical mystery series

Jane and the man of the cloth (Jane Austen Mystery #2)



Author: Stephanie Barron

Genre: cozy mystery

Page number: 335

First published: 1997

Setting: Lyme Regis in 1804

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: It is a truth universally acknowledged, that the expectation of pleasure is grnerally preferred to its eventual attainment – the attainment being marred, at its close, by the resumption of quotidian routine made onerous by the very diversions so lately enjoyed.

One sentence comment: The story gets better to the end, and I realize that Lyme Regis  is actually a good place for a mystery because its Jurassic-age site welcomes new people.

     Lyme Regis is Austen's favorite town, a  medieval town on the coast of Dorset. Barren cleverly drew together exciting elements of Lyme Regis, such as archeology, smuggling, and the historical fire, to form a mystery. She even added a touch of romance to Austen. However, the course of story development is very bland, and Austen is highly unlikely to have this sort of romance.

 

November Book Challenges

 

Nov # a book published before 1900

Lady Susan



Author: Jane Austen

Genre: epistolary

Page number: 58

First published: 1871

Setting: England in Regency era

Rating: 2 stars

First sentence: My dear brother – I can no longer refuse myself the pleasure of profiting by your kind invitation when we last parted of spending some weeks with you at Churchill, and, therefore, if quite convenient to you and Mrs Vernon to receive me at present, I shall hope within a few days to be introduced to a sister whom I have so long desired to be acquainted with.

One sentence comment: It feels odd to read an epistolary novel full of calculation for marriages written by a young lady under 20.

          It means that Austen never believed in love. A romantic person became realistic because she experiences hardship in life as she grows older. But if Austen saw through the mask of marriages as a teen, how could she write romantic novels in later years? I start to think that Austen had known that marriages are business from the very beginning.

 

Nov # a book with a reading word in the title

Mayhem at the Orient Express ( A League of Literary Ladies Mystery #1)



Author: Kylie Logan

Genre: cozy mystery

Page number:282

First published: 2013

Setting: An island off Ohio at present time

Rating: 2 stars

First sentence: If it weren’t for Jerry Garcia peeing on my pansies, I never would have joined the League of Literary Ladies.

One sentence comment: It's most  disappointing that the author came up with the idea of a book club in a mystery, but had no merit of book discussion.

 

In terms of character building, dialogs, and plot development, this book achieves nothing. From the very beginning, since the three women protagonists appeared, which seemed to signal a possibly interesting mystery, they quarreled up to 50 pages before the murder happened. You would think things could have taken a good turn, but their conflict went on while the author were introducing more flat characters and boring conversation. I didn't give up the book simply because I wanted to find out the solution. Then I can sum up my experience, that is never trust a mystery series if its first book is published after 2010.

 

 

Nov # a book included on Goodread’s 1000 books to read before you die

The Awakening



Author: Kate Chopin

Genre: fiction

Page number: 113

First published: 1892

Setting: Louisiana, USA in the late 19th century

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: A green and yellow parrot, which hung in a cage outside the door, kept repeating over and over: ‘Allez ous-en! Allez vous-en! Sapristi! That’s all right!’

One sentence comment: Told like a slow paced romance, this book, however, activates my investigating mind, eager to find out the outcome.

 

It’s a languid story about Mrs Edna Pontellier, a 21 year-old woman with children, supplied a comfortable life by her husband. She is involved with two men, Robert and Arobin, one she loves and the other she is pursued by. The courting in this book is peculiar and almost unrealistic for a modern reader, like me; however, over a hundred years apart, I get a chance to savor the writing about the powerlessness of a young woman. When she decided that she ‘no longer one of Mr Pontellier’s possessions to dispose of or not,’ I guess it is why the book was banned.

 

Nov # a book you would consider to be light reading

A is for Alibi



Author: Sue Grafton

Genre: soft-boiled mystery

Page number: 308

First published: 1982

Setting: CA, USA, in 1980’s

Rating: 2 stars

First sentence: My name is Kinsey Millhone.

One sentence comment: It’s hard to relate to any of the characters in the book.

 

          The first sentence is bland and so are many others. I’m disappointed about this book since I thought this long running series must be enchanting. It only tried to tell a drama of a group of non feeling people.

October Challenge

 


# a book by an author who is dead

The Cat Who Could read Backwards ( Cat Who mystery #1)

Author: Lilian Jackson Braun

Genre: Cozy Mystery

Page number: 250

First published: 1966

Setting: Midwest in the US

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: Jim Qwilleran, whose name had confounded typesetters and proofreaders for two decades, arrived fifteen minutes early for his appointment with the managing editor of the Daily Fluxion.

One sentence comment: Braun’s writing style is my favorite, for almost every sentence she had written took me by surprise.

     While I was reading the book, I couldn’t believe that the book was published almost sixty years ago. It read as if it was published in recent years, and the language is so refleshing. I’m not a pet lover but the vivid description of the cat intrigues and delights me. No wonder the series is still in the backlist as popular paperbacks.

 


 # a book in which a character mourns the loss of another

Murder on Marble Row (Gaslight Mystery #6)

Author: Victoria Thompson

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 313

First published: 2004

Setting: New York in the late 19th century

Rating: 5 stars

First sentence: Frank didn’t actually heard the explosion that morning.

One sentence comment: The author always has the gift of using an intriguing opening to remind us of the protagonist’s complicated relationship with the heroine, which is the major spark of the series.

     In this book, Thompson tackles the issue of anarchists bombing. What’s really exciting is that Theodore Roosevelt, then Commissioner in the police force, appeared and assigned the investigation to the protagonist, Frank. The author has a great talent to mingle a serious issue with romantic relationship. The interaction between the leading characters, Frank and Sarah, is getting more and more interesting as the book series develop. It will be a shame if I miss one of the books in the middle of the series. Frank’s thoughts about women, including Sarah, are considered sexsual discrimination but was his era’s common sense so I always read with a chuckle. I am reminded of the controversial statements that one of our recent presidential candidates made about women in Taiwan. For example, he referred to a young woman in a governmental position as ‘pretty enough to be a receptionist.’ I’m thinking perhaps there is not much difference between the late 19th century and the present time.

     Besides linking issues relating to our time, the greatest talent of the author is to make the protagonist, Frank, adorable, even though he is a typical representative in patriarchy. I sympathize him because men’s traditional role in a conservative society was crumbling as more women started to take professional responsibilities in the American society. However the integrity of a traditional role he had held still shone on him, and for this reason we accept him as who he was.

 


# a book with a “death” word in the title

Puzzled to Death ( Puzzle Lady Mystery #3)

Author: Parnell Hall

Genre: cozy mystery

Page number: 391

First published: 2001

Setting: Near Boston present time

Rating: stars: 4 stars

First sentence: Cora Felton pulled the heavy knit sweater around her shoulders, crinkled her nose, squinted her eye against the sun, and declared: “I. Hate, Fall.”

One sentence comment: It is a marvel to connect a crossword tournament and a domestic murder.

     With the series progressing, I can see both the murder design and conversations are getting better from the crossword guru writer, Hall.  I also detect scarcasm where the fake puzzle lady, who is interested in muder investigation is to some degree an illiterate in the eyes of the real puzzle constructer in the story. I have enjoyed the murder series but can hardly do much to the puzzles the author offered in the plot. Fortunately, knowledge of the puzzles is not intrinsic for solving the murders.

 


# a book with a white cover

Revolutionary Road

Author: Richard Yates

Genre: fiction

Page number: 463

First published: 1961

Setting: a village at western Connecticut in 1955

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: The final dying sounds of their dress rehearsal left the Laurel Players with nothing to do but stand there, silent and helpless, blinking out over the footlights of an empty auditorium.

One sentence comment: It seems that women of either types, single-willed or constantly nagging, are horror to the author.

     I bought this book more than ten years ago, but wasn’t impressed by reading it. At present this is the only English book with a white cover in my TBR, so I decided to reread it.

The story is set at the time when a woman had the luxury of being a housewife and getting her husband’s support to attend a performing group to manifest her ambition. At first, I felt out of place, having nothing to link with the characters thus lost my interests. In Taiwan, our society has never been so rich either in material or in spirit that ordinary working people have the ability to pursue art as an integral part of life. While I see the narrator living in heaven, he states that his people “take the larger absurdities of deadly dull jobs in the city and deadly dull homes in the suburbs.” However, when I kept reading, I resumed curiosity by appreciating the author’s delicate language and understanding that every era or place has its problems for us to trace.

 

September Challenge

 Sep # read the next book from a series you’ve started

Last Puzzle & Testament ( Puzzle Lady #2)




Author: Parnell Hall

Genre: cozy mystery

Page number: 370

First published: 2000

Setting: Connecticut, USA

Time: present

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: It all began with a break-in.

One sentence comment: It’s not only a clever crossword puzzle, but also a real life puzzle.

 

          I was amazed while the crossword puzzle being split by four parts, and wondered how the story would lead to a meaningful solution. The outcome was really surprising and the last scene was very satisfying. My criticism is there are quite a few unnecessary conversation.

 

 

Sep # read something cozy

Jane and the Unpleasantness at Scargrave Manor (Jane Austen Mystery #1)


Author: Stephanie Barron

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 318

First published: 1996

Setting: Hertfordshire, England, 1802-3

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: In the spring of 1995, I visited my good friends Paul and Lucy Westmoreland.

One sentence comment: Barron is an amazing dreamer for she invented a bunch of Austen’s letters and journals to fill the gaps of her unknown life then make them into an unprecedented mystery.

 

It took me a while to get used to the early 19th century writing style, but soon found my heart caught in Isobel’s misery. 1802 was the year that Austen turned down her suiter, who was possibly the last she might encounter as she was already 27 years old without inheritance. Her friend Isobel, a newly-wed Countess, invited her to Scargrave Manor but turned out to be a widow with accusation of murdering her aged husband. What can be better to get rid of Jane’s lament than solving the case?

 

I admire Barron’s design of annotations when mentioning the law or customs in Austen’s era in the Austen’s letters and journals. They give readers more understanding about Austen’s time. The twisty plot is great for it expands to an unexpected level. Austen’s life thus exceeded domestic domain seen from her novels. However, I wish Barron could have written the mystery from the third person point of view rather than the first person’s. If the writing style had been modern, the series would have been among the most popular. 

Sep # Read something short

Black Beauty


Author:  Anna Sewell

Genre: classic animal literature

Page number: 201

First published: 1877

Setting: farm in the UK, 19th century

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: The first place that I can well remember, was a large pleasant meadow with a pond of clear water in it.

One sentence comment: I had never imagined how hard a horse’s life is before I read this book.

 

This book was simply written but carried knowledge that we modern people have lost. It is surprising that trauma in animals was understood so well in the 19th century. However, we have to educate people how trauma can influence a person’s behavior in modern day.

 

 

August challenges: BB

 

August # a big book (400+ pages)

Firefly Summer


Author: Maeve Binchy

Genre: fiction

Page number: 645

First published: 1987

Setting: small town Ireland

Time: 1960’s

Rating: 5 stars

First sentence: The sun came in at a slant and hit all the rings and marks on the bar counter.

One sentence comment: It is a page turner, but you only want to turn every page slowly enough to taste the flavor long lost in the modern world.

         I used to be misled by the title, Firefly Summer, which has received a great acclaim among internet book clubs. I thought to myself, even if the title was eye catching, what Binchy could write if it was about children playing with fireflies in the summer. Then I found out that I was completely wrong. Besides, it can be any nostalgic story, but told by Binchy, it trnsforms into a marvel. Like her previous books I have read, it urges me to read on as if I am reading a thriller. But far from it, her book reads like a heart-warming romance. How could a romance in this day still takes me for surprise, or even though I tried to predict it, there was still magic to lead me on, to make me bury my head in her brick-shaped thick volume.

          The book begins with an introduction of a wise and strong woman, Kate, common to other Binchy novels, then suddenly into the quiet town comes Patrick, a felt-like Jean Valjean character from Les Miserables, but he was from a different prison, materialistic America, to return to Ireland to give justice, as he thought, to his home town people. But Kate is warned, and we wonder, will Patrick soon inflict damage to the whole town?

          Binchy had a strong sense of community and land. She explored different values, about those between cities and towns, not to mention aspects of christian belief. Through a single young solicitor, Fergus, we see his love, larger than life, for the livelihood of all the people in this town. Binchy also gave insights into things I had never thought about, such as how Pretestant vicar live among the Catholic community. She wrote stories of characters like kaleidoscope. They cater for diverse appetites of readers of different experiences and personalities. Many times I like to listen to debates about topics or advice that one character gives to another. There are also a circle of teenagers. They make troubles and adventures. Readers get what they need from multiple-character books by Binchy.

          Last year since I discovered Binchy’s first novel, Light a Penny Candle, I have decided to read all her novels in order of publication. This is the third book and it takes a grimmer turn than its predecessors. It further puts me into the boots of the protagonists’ crisis and ponder about life. There is always so much in her story that moves me so I think and feel about, either fate, decisions, or faith. Whenever I read her book, I was thinking that there was no way the next book she had written could be better than this one. But this is the third book of hers and I am still think in the same way and will be eager to check out the answer from her next book.


August # A bargain book (half price from the bookstore website.)

The Fallen Angel (Gabriel Allon #12)


Author: Daniel Silva

Genre: spy mystery

Page number: 448

First published: 2012

Setting: Vatican, Israel and other countries

Time: 21 century

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: It was Niccolo moretti, care taker of St. Peter’s Basilica, who made the discovery that started it all.

One sentence comment: Mingled with history of art and religion, this book takes a modern reader to Vatican and Israel, their past and present.

          I usually read a book series following its published order. Months after I read the first book of the series and decided not to follow it, The Fallen Angel came up as a half-price sale on the bookshop website I usually surf. A sudden impulse gave me one more chance to read the series again.

This time I have been amazed by its exotic settings, various places of Vatican, and its historical telling about the lost civilization of old Italy. The same as when writing the plot in Israel, the author can brief through the Roman Emperor’s massacre in the 70AD to the Six-Day War effortlessly without tiring readers. Of course we also get a glimpse of the present tension of the archeologist war between the Jews and the Palestinians.

When I read to the middle of the book, I became bored. Part of the reason is I was not familiar enough with nowaday terrorism and details of Nazi history to appreciate tours of different locations . However, I think the major reason is the way the book was written. It didn’t tell people’s life stories like Ruta Sepetys did in her two books about Stalin and the fascist dictatorship Franco. Silva only intended his book to be a series of dangerous operations, a thriller and nothing more. 

Aug # a book with a black or blue bookcover

Why Mermaids Sing ( Sebastian St. Cyr Mystery #3)


Author: C. S. Harris

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 329

First published: 2007

Setting: London

Time: 1811

Rating: 5 stars

First sentence: Fear twisted Dominic Stanton’s stomach, compressed his chest until his breath came shallow and quick.

One sentence comment: This book prolongs my enjoyment of reading Harris’ language art.

          I adore this historical mystery series for the lovable characters and amusing conversations. Since the first book of the series, I have been reading with excitement, admiring the author’s way of dealing with plots. The series is full of lovable characters that fill me with curiosity – what will happen to them? While people follow a series for the like of the detective, I’m not particularly taken with the protagonist, a lovesick wayward aristocrat, Sebastian, whose relationship with a beautiful actress, Kat, is way too cliché. Even so, whenever he brings up people’s disapproval or even fright, I couldn’t help burst into laughter. Harris has created a man particular romantic, reckless, intuitive and resourceful, a mixture of virility. I don’t like his characteristics but grow to like reading about him.

          This particular book, the third of the series, is mainly about a series of murders inspired by a poem written by John Donne, a sixteenth-century poet. My favorite character, Sir Henry, who is a compassionate local magistrate, asks Sebastian to help crack the case. As a continuing story, Kat’s spy work for the French is on the verge of revelation. Another of my favorite characters, Lord Jarvis, a ruthless man and faithful servant to the Prince, threatens to destroy Kat. What a great combination! What’s more delightful is my favorite heroine, Hero, Jarvis’ daughter, makes appearance in this book after the first book of the series. I have read somewhere that she is going to replace Kat later. I’m looking forwards to keeping reading this series.

 

August # A book with the letter B occurring twice on the front cover


Simply Unforgettable ( Simply Quartet #1)

Author: Mary Balogh

Genre: historical romance

Page number: 422

First published: 2005

Setting: London and Bath

Time: Regency era

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: It never snowed for Christmas.

One sentence comment: A romance through psychological depth and realistic reminiscence is the only way to win my heart.

I was quite fascinated by the beginning of the book, where two young people begin what they thought a one-night liaison. Perhaps just because I’ve never read a romance so I found novelty in their psychology and conversation. Besides, as a regency romance, it gave me curiosity to check out the things mentioned in the book, such as the song the protagonist sang, Handel’s I Know That My Redeemer Liveth. It was actually a melody I often heard.

 I like some of the discussion between characters, such as when two women were talking about the possibility of whether a woman can live in Independence. However, it is disappointing that the ending seems to distort a progressing course of women’s mind. I agree that the author has a great technique to depict diferent characters in depth; however, she couldn’t go beyond the tropes that a romance genre can offer.

 

July Monthly Challenge

 

July # A book with an author whose first or last name begins with p, l, a, n, or t.

Magpie Murders



Author: Anthony Horowitz

Genre: meta mystery

Page number: 464

First published: 2016

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: A bottle of wine.

One sentence comment: The idea of a mystery within a mystery is a genius invention; however, the structure of the book is dull.

 

          I ordered the book because the same name TV program adapted from the novel is brilliant so I wonder how Horowitz wrote it. However, I am disappointed because his way of presenting the two mysteries are rigid and can not compare with the TV program. I have a theory that if a TV program is better than a novel then the novel is not successful. Besides, I hardly see any witty sentences while reading. With so many repeated ideas and sentences, the book should be cut in half.

 

 

July # A book with plants on the cover

Persuasion


Author: Jane Austen

Genre: classic romance

Page number: 295

First published: 1817

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: Sir Walter Elliot, of Kellynch Hall, in Somersetshire, was a man who, for his own amusement, never took up any book but the Boronetage; there he found occupation for an idle hour, and consolation in a distressed one; there his faculties were roused into admiration and respect, by contemplating the limited remnant of the earliest patents; there any unwelcome sensations, arising from domestic affairs changed naturally into pity and contempt as he turned over the almost endless creations of the last century; and there, if every other leaf were powerless, he could read his own history with an interest which never failed.

One sentence comment: This book is the least persuading romance among Austen’s novels.

 

I can see why Persuasion is the least popular novel among Austen’s six major works. There is a serious discrepancy in the book. On the one hand, the book is far away from Austen's previous romantic novels because it tackles realistic financial matters gravely from the very beginning without jokes. Therefore, it was meant to be treated seriously. On the other hand, the happy ending between Anne and Wenworth is too incredible for modern day readers. In fact, there isn’t much difference between marriages then and now in terms of a trade-off between wealth and youth. It is not unusual for women to chase after well-off men even they are ten years or above older. How could it be possible that Wentworth, considered a capital match for young women with admiration, should come back to Ann, whose beauty and family wealth are both dwindling?

     Persuasion is Austen's last completed novel and published posthumously. I suspect that she intended to review it and to make it as entertaining as her previous books but death came unexpectedly. Therefore, without disguise, we can see Austen's core theme more clearly. It is lament for life going downward without hope when wealth and youth are both used up. However, as a romantic novelist, she still designed a favorable solution for the happiness of the heroine.

     I am not against romantic love but it must be plausible in a novel. Austen is a romantic writer but she is beyond romantic writing and renowned for her realistic social accounts so I expect more from her. Romantic love in P&P and S&S are all plausible, more or less, because male protagonists all have weaknesses so that they are attracted to women inferior to their social and monetary status, but Wentworth just seems self-contained and has no needs to return to Ann. Unless Austen decided to write a pious novel that used Wentworth as a metaphor of Jesus. That’s the only explanation because Jesus is perfect and he comes to save anyone who is repentant.

 

July # a book from your TBR

By Book or by Crook (Lighthouse Library Mystery #1)


Author: Eva Gates

Genre: cozy mystery

Page number: 327

First published: 2015

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: Only in the very back of my mind, in my most secret dreams, did I ever dare hope I’d have such a moment.

One sentence comment: Using Jane Austen‘s first print collection as a gimmick, this book has turned a mystery into a comedy.

 

I had chosen this book among a few book-related cozy mystery series, perhaps for its book cover, or perhaps for its title, whatever reason I can not remember well. I adore the book cover - a sunny blue view near the sea and I think the title is clever. It is a play of a pun, by hook or by crook. Obviously, this book series use a similar way to glamor each book. Reading this book, sometimes I see witty sentences; sometimes it reads like a boring diary. Characters are described vividly but the protagonist is too young and girl-minded to raise my interest. The plot is terrible, because it's neither effective nor affective. How could a mystery mingle murder, book theft, and ghost stories, along with a detective noted for his handsome appearance and dating attempt to one of the suspects. It's absurd. However, I value this book for its well-written English.

 

 

July # DNF

Silver Pigs ( a Marcus Didius Falco Novel #1)

Author: Lindsey Davis

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 328

First published: 1989

Rating: 1 star

First sentence: When the girl came rushing up the steps, I decided she was wearing far too many clothes.

One sentence comment: Who would be interested in a frivolous man as a protagonist?

 

          Look at the first sentence, and you will be surprised to see how many pages the protagonist was rambling on the clothes of the woman who ran for her life. As if time stopped. I should really admire the author for her writing technique.

          It took me a long time to wonder: what’s the meaning of this series. Perhaps it tried to tell me that Britain was full of brutal killings during the Roman reign in AD 70; perhaps it tried to show me what the mines and slaves who worked in them were like. Perhaps it told us modern readers that it had divorces and women could live independently at the golden age of Roman Empire. However, I don’t intend to read the Roman history. As a mystery series, it doesn’t propel me to want to read more about the protagonists and the plot.

 

 

Monthly Challenges for June

 

June # title contains at least 5 of the letters of supercalifragilcexpialidocious

The Last of Her Kind



Author: Sigrid Nunez

Genre: fiction

Page number: 407

First published: 2006

Rating: four stars

First sentence: We had been living together for about a week when my roommate told me she had asked specifically to be paired with a girl from a world as different as possible from her own.

One sentence comment: It’s like an American social history from 60’s to 80’s seen through the lives of two women from contrasting social background.

 

I spent three weeks reading this book slowly because I felt the protagonists were so real and their lives penetrated into my mental picture of American culture, which was so sophisticated at the time that I, as Taiwanese, could hardly imagine it before. 

 

June # Goodreads rating 4.0 plus

The Giver


Author: Lois Lowry

Genre: Dystopian fiction

Page number: 225

First published: 1993

Rating: 3 stars

First sentence: It was almost December, and Jonas was beginning to be frightened.

One sentence comment: I never like dystopian fiction except the novel 1984 by George Orwell; however, I can see this book is well structured, enlightening and easy to read.

 

June # a book with a cover you love

Murder on Mulberry Bend (Gaslight mystery #5)



Author: Victoria Thompson

Genre: historical mystery

Page number: 343

First published: 2003

Rating: 4 stars

First sentence: “I hope you enjoy the evening.”

One sentence comment: Like in other books of the series, the protagonists are fun and intriguing.

 

I have been following the series, which give a midwife the role of detective, and this is the fifth book in the series. This book becomes my favorite among its predecessors.  It has the longest length, while others are less than 300 pages. It encompasses various elements that make the book most interesting. First, it delineates psychological complexity humorously of both protagonists, Sarah and Frank, from the very beginning. Second, it shows a charity at the time to save girls in the Italian district 200 years ago. Third, it provides religious wisdom and  crude reality at the same time, but Sarah combats both with her sense of justice and reasoning. However, I am disappointed about the ending, which I think is a cliché and incredible. That’s why I only give this book four stars.